Time For Town Hall Meetings In Canada

National Post editorial board: Canadian health care is no model

Posted: August 18, 2009, 7:52 AM by NP Editor

The last two presidents of the Canadian Medical Association (CMA) have both been staunch advocates of increased private care. The incoming president, Anne Doig of Saskatoon, who will be installed this week, says our health-care system is "imploding." While not as committed to private options as her predecessors, Dr. Doig acknowledges our current universal public system is "unsustainable." She also argues we should not fear private options, but rather should implement whatever models from around the world -- be they public or private -- that produce the best results for patients. On the other hand, the physician who will replace Dr. Doig next summer, Ottawa's Dr. Jeff Turnbull, promises to be a passionate defender of the government health monopoly during his one-year term.

Overall, then, three of the four most-recent CMA presidents and presidents-elect have argued to varying degrees that private options for patients are inevitable; just one believes our current government-administered system can be prolonged. Only a dogmatic left-wing outlet such as the Toronto Star editorial page would view this --as it argued in an editorial on Sunday -- as proof that a "fresh [pro-medicare] approach may be taking hold" at the CMA, an approach that will "ensure the reactionary American debate over the future of its health care does not poison our own."

Click here to read more...