Monday, June 30, 2008

SCA Upholds Free Speech But HRC Doesn't


Canada: Radio host's Nazi remark deemed fair comment

ANYTHING is OK if you are criticizing conservatives:

To be fair to some of the wingnuts on the left I don't think they aren't consciously malicious but they seem to have a reading and comprehension problem and even an inkling in a posting that the poster is on the right turns on their blinders.......
"The Supreme Court of Canada has unanimously ruled that an outspoken Vancouver radio host is not liable for defamatory statements. The court upheld a previous B. C. Supreme Court decision that the right to fair comment protected "shock jock" Rafe Mair's statements in an on-air editorial about Kari Simpson, a public figure whom Mr. Mair compared to Nazis and Ku Klux Klan members...

On a Vancouver talk show in 1999, Mr. Mair criticized Ms. Simpson for having anti-gay views and said she reminded him of Adolf Hitler and prominent Ku Klux Klan members. At the time, Ms. Simpson had a reputation as a leader "of those opposed to any positive portrayal of a gay lifestyle," wrote Justice Ian Binnie....

"We live in a free country where people have as much right to express outrageous and ridiculous opinions as moderate ones," the ruling says.

Source

If the same criteria are applied, Mark Steyn should have an easy run once he gets his case into a real court.

No comments:

About Me

My photo
I lean to the right but I still have a heart and if I have a mission it is to respond to attacks on people not available to protect themselves and to point out the hypocrisy of the left at every opportunity.MY MAJOR GOAL IS HIGHLIGHT THE HYPOCRISY AND STUPIDITY OF THE LEFTISTS ON TORONTO CITY COUNCIL. Last word: In the final analysis this blog is a relief valve for my rants/raves.

Blog Archive